IELTS Task 2: Elderly living with family — Band 6.5 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people think that elderly people should live with their families. Others believe they should live in special communities with people their own age. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Band 6.5 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that elderly people should live with their families. Others believe they should live in…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: Some people think that elderly people should live with their families. Others believe they should live in special communities with people their own age. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

In many countries the number of elderly people is growing, so there is a discussion about where they should live. Some people think that old people should stay with their families, but others believe that special communities for old people are better. In this essay I will give both views and my opinion.

First of all, living with the family has several advantages. The elderly people feel loved and they are not lonely because they can talk with their children and grandchildren every day. In many Asian countries, for example, it is a tradition that the children take care of their parents when they become old, and this is considered as a duty. Also, family members can help with daily activities such as cooking or going to the doctor, and it is cheaper than paying a nursing home. Moreover, grandparents can pass the family values to the young generation.

However, there are also arguments for special communities. In these places, old people live with others of the same age, so they have common interests and they can make new friends. There are doctors and nurses who work twenty-four hours, which is safer if the person has a serious illness. In addition, young families today are very busy, and sometimes they have not enough time or space to look after an old person. This can create stress and conflicts in the house. For instance, an elderly person may feel like a burden for his children.

In my opinion, it depends on the health of the elderly person. If they are healthy, they should live with their family because it is better for emotional life. But if they need constant medical care, the special community is a better solution.

In conclusion, both options have their good sides. The most important is that the old people are respected and that their needs are taken into account.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The range is adequate for the topic (nursing home, family values, common interests), but it is limited and repetitive, with 'old people' and 'elderly people' reused throughout. Word choice errors such as 'it is better for emotional life' and 'pass the family values' show imprecision in less common phrasing.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 Both views are discussed and the opinion that it depends on the elderly person's health is clear and relevant. The family-side arguments (loneliness, tradition in Asian countries, the cost of a nursing home) are better extended than the community side, where 'This can create stress and conflicts in the house' is only briefly supported.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The essay has a clear five-paragraph structure and uses sequencing such as 'First of all', 'Also', 'Moreover' and 'In addition'. These are somewhat mechanical, and the repeated 'old people' / 'elderly people' phrasing leans on repetition instead of pronoun referencing.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The range is adequate for the topic (nursing home, family values, common interests), but it is limited and repetitive, with 'old people' and 'elderly people' reused throughout. Word choice errors such as 'it is better for emotional life' and 'pass the family values' show imprecision in less common phrasing.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 The essay uses relative clauses, conditionals ('If they are healthy, they should live...') and linked clauses, but errors appear regularly in the more ambitious sentences: 'this is considered as a duty' and 'they have not enough time or space'. Meaning is never lost.

Marked mistakes

  1. this is considered as a duty
    this is considered a duty (GA)
    The verb 'consider' takes its complement directly without 'as' in this passive construction.
  2. may feel like a burden for his children
    may feel like a burden on his children (LR)
    'Burden' takes 'on' before the people who have to carry it: 'a burden on someone'.
  3. they have not enough time or space
    they do not have enough time or space (GA)
    Modern English forms this negative with the auxiliary 'do not have' rather than 'have not'.
  4. The most important is that the old people are respected
    The most important thing is that old people are respected (GA)
    The superlative needs a noun such as 'thing', and the article before 'old people' is not needed in a general statement.
  5. it is better for emotional life
    it is better for their emotional wellbeing (LR)
    'Emotional life' is not a standard collocation here; 'emotional wellbeing' expresses the idea naturally.

What would raise the band

Revise passive and negative structures such as 'considered as' and 'have not enough', and vary your wording for 'old people' with terms like 'senior citizens' or 'older relatives' to raise lexical range.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Some people think that elderly people should live with their families. Others believe they should live in special communities with people their own age. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

As populations age, families and governments must decide where older people are best looked after. Some argue that elderly relatives belong in the family home, while others see specialist retirement communities as a better option. I believe that the right choice depends largely on the person's health and wishes, although for those who can still manage independently, a family setting is often preferable.

The main attraction of living with relatives is emotional. Older people who share a home with children and grandchildren are less likely to suffer from isolation, which research has linked to depression and faster cognitive decline. They remain part of everyday family life, contributing by cooking, minding children or simply offering advice, and this sense of usefulness is important for self-esteem. Financially, multi-generational households also share the costs of housing and utilities, which is a significant consideration where pensions are low.

However, living together is not always practical or desirable. Adult children who work long hours cannot supervise a parent with dementia or limited mobility, and constant caregiving can lead to exhaustion and resentment. Retirement communities can offer something family homes rarely can: round-the-clock nursing, accessible buildings and a ready-made social circle of people with similar interests and experiences. Many residents report that they feel freer there, because they are not afraid of being a burden on the younger generation.

For these reasons, I would not advocate a single solution. Where an elderly person is reasonably healthy, living with or near family preserves relationships and dignity. When medical needs become demanding, a specialised community is likely to provide safer and better care, as long as relatives continue to visit regularly. The most important factor is that the older person takes part in the decision rather than having it made for them.

In conclusion, both arrangements have genuine strengths, and the best arrangement is the one that fits the individual's health, finances and preferences.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource at 8: The introduction gives a nuanced position, that the choice depends on health and wishes, and the conclusion remains consistent with it. Each view is developed with causes and consequences, for example dementia care and caregiver exhaustion on one side and a sense of usefulness on the other. The claim that 'Many residents report that they feel freer there' is stated without support.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The introduction gives a nuanced position, that the choice depends on health and wishes, and the conclusion remains consistent with it. Each view is developed with causes and consequences, for example dementia care and caregiver exhaustion on one side and a sense of usefulness on the other. The claim that 'Many residents report that they feel freer there' is stated without support.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Paragraphs have a clear topic, and 'The main attraction', 'However' and 'For these reasons' mark the argument. Reference chains such as 'this sense of usefulness' are precise. The final sentence repeats the idea of both arrangements, creating slight redundancy.
Lexical Resource Band 8 The writer uses precise topic vocabulary such as 'cognitive decline', 'multi-generational households', 'round-the-clock nursing' and 'a ready-made social circle'. Collocations are accurate, with minor repetition of 'arrangement' in the closing sentence.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 Sentence forms vary widely, including participle clauses ('contributing by cooking, minding children or simply offering advice') and the contrastive 'rather than having it made for them'. Nearly all sentences are error-free and punctuation is controlled.

Marked mistakes

  1. the best arrangement is the one that fits the individual's health, finances and preferences
    the best option is the one that fits the individual's health, finances and preferences (LR)
    'Arrangements' appears earlier in the same sentence, so a synonym avoids the repetition.
  2. Many residents report that they feel freer there
    Some residents report that they feel freer there, for example because they keep their independence (TR)
    A generalisation about residents needs a hedge or a brief reason to be convincing.

What would raise the band

Back the generalisations about retirement community residents with a clear reason or hedge, and avoid repeating key nouns like 'arrangement' within the same sentence.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 essay builds a conditional position (health, independence, and the elderly person's own say) and supports each side with specific points such as links between isolation and cognitive decline and the strain on working adult children. The 6.5 essay reaches a similar conclusion but uses mostly basic ideas and a general Asian-tradition example. It also has errors ('considered as a duty', 'have not enough time', 'burden for'), and its wording is simpler and more repetitive.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people think that elderly people should live with their families. Others believe they should live in special communities with people their own age. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →