Some people think that the names and photographs of convicted criminals should be published in newspapers. Others believe this is wrong. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that the names and photographs of convicted criminals should be published in newspapers.…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Some people think that the names and photographs of convicted criminals should be published in newspapers. Others believe this is wrong. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Some people think that newspapers should publish the names and photos of criminals who were found guilty, but others say this is wrong. In this essay I will discuss both opinions and explain my point of view.
Firstly, supporters of publication say that it is a good punishment. A criminal who knows that everybody will see his face in the newspaper will feel ashamed, and this can stop other people from committing the same crime. Moreover, the public have a right to know who are the dangerous people living near them. For example, if a person was found guilty of stealing from elderly people, the neighbours should know about it to protect themselves. Also, it make the system more open and honest, because nothing is hidden from the society.
On the other hand, there are strong arguments against this idea. The main problem is that the family of the criminal also suffers. His wife and children did nothing wrong, but people can laugh at them or refuse to talk to them. Furthermore, after the criminal finishes his sentence, it will be very hard to find a job if everybody knows about his past. As a result he may return to crime because he have no other choice. Another problem is that sometimes the court makes a mistake, and an innocent person gets his name destroyed forever.
In my opinion, publishing the names and photographs is not a good idea in most of cases. The punishment is already given by the court, and the media should not add one more. However, I think that it can be acceptable for the most dangerous criminals, for example sexual offenders, so that the people can protect their children.
To conclude, I think publishing is wrong except for very serious crimes, because it affects innocent family members and prevents the criminal from starting a new life.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 5.5 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 5.5: Vocabulary is adequate but plain: 'good punishment', 'very hard' and 'one more' stay at a basic level. There are few less common items, though 'ashamed' and 'sentence' are used correctly, and 'in most of cases' shows a fixed-phrase slip.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | Both views are covered (shame and deterrence, public right to know versus harm to families, job prospects and wrongful convictions) and the writer gives a clear opinion with an exception for sexual offenders. Development is mostly general, for example 'people can laugh at them' is not extended with any real consequence. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | The five-paragraph plan is clear and linkers such as 'Moreover', 'Furthermore' and 'As a result' keep the argument moving. The linking is somewhat mechanical, and the 'Firstly' that opens the first body paragraph is never followed by a 'Secondly'. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5.5 | Vocabulary is adequate but plain: 'good punishment', 'very hard' and 'one more' stay at a basic level. There are few less common items, though 'ashamed' and 'sentence' are used correctly, and 'in most of cases' shows a fixed-phrase slip. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | Simple and complex sentences are mixed, including conditionals and 'so that' clauses. Subject-verb agreement fails repeatedly ('it make', 'he have'), which does not block meaning but appears in several body-paragraph sentences. |
Marked mistakes
-
it make the system more open and honest
it makes the system more open and honest (GA)
A singular subject 'it' needs the third-person -s form 'makes'. -
he have no other choice
he has no other choice (GA)
'He' takes 'has', not 'have'. -
in most of cases
in most cases (LR)
The collocation is 'in most cases' without 'of'. -
who are the dangerous people living near them
which dangerous individuals live near them (LR)
In an embedded question the subject comes before the verb ('who the dangerous people living near them are'); a simpler noun clause such as 'which dangerous individuals live near them' is more natural. -
people can laugh at them or refuse to talk to them
people may bully them at school or exclude them socially, which harms the children's wellbeing (TR)
The point about the family is asserted but its effect is not explained.
What would raise the band
Proofread for third-person -s and 'have/has' errors, as they appear in two different sentences. Then extend one argument in each paragraph with a concrete consequence instead of a general statement.
Band 8.5
Prompt: Some people think that the names and photographs of convicted criminals should be published in newspapers. Others believe this is wrong. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
The question of whether the media should name and show convicted offenders touches on public safety, deterrence and individual dignity. Some regard publication as a legitimate form of accountability, while others consider it unjust. I take the second position for most offences, with a narrow exception for dangerous offenders.
Those in favour make two main points. The first is deterrence: the prospect of seeing one's face and name in the local paper may discourage a person from, say, drink-driving or fraud, since the damage to reputation can be as feared as a fine. The second concerns protection. Communities have a reasonable interest in knowing if a convicted burglar or abuser lives nearby, and open reporting of court outcomes is a long-standing principle of transparent justice.
Against this, publication creates punishments that no court has imposed. Once an offender's photograph circulates online, it can never be fully removed, which makes rehabilitation extremely difficult; employers hesitate to hire someone whose conviction appears at the top of a search. This may push former prisoners towards reoffending, the very outcome that society wishes to avoid. The offender's relatives, including children, may also be harassed or ostracised despite having committed no crime. In addition, any judicial system can make errors, and an incorrectly convicted person whose picture has been published may never recover their reputation even after an appeal succeeds.
On balance, I believe the media should report the facts of cases and sentences but withhold identifying details for the majority of offenders. The exception should be those considered an ongoing danger to others, such as violent or sexual offenders, where an official, regulated register provides the necessary protection without turning the press into an instrument of punishment.
In conclusion, naming and shaming might deter some crime, yet it harms rehabilitation and innocent families. Restricting publication to the gravest cases strikes a sensible balance between public safety and fairness.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8 · CC 8.5 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5
The weakest criterion is Task Response at 8: Both views are presented with specific supporting points (deterrence through reputational damage, community protection versus unofficial punishment, rehabilitation, harm to relatives, wrongful conviction). The position is stated in the introduction and sustained to the conclusion, with a carefully limited exception for violent or sexual offenders. A few claims, such as the photograph 'can never be fully removed', are slightly overstated.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | Both views are presented with specific supporting points (deterrence through reputational damage, community protection versus unofficial punishment, rehabilitation, harm to relatives, wrongful conviction). The position is stated in the introduction and sustained to the conclusion, with a carefully limited exception for violent or sexual offenders. A few claims, such as the photograph 'can never be fully removed', are slightly overstated. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | The structure moves smoothly from 'Those in favour make two main points' with 'The first... The second...' to 'Against this' and 'On balance'. Referencing is neat, as in 'the very outcome that society wishes to avoid', and each paragraph has one clear focus. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8.5 | Precise, topic-specific vocabulary such as 'accountability', 'ostracised', 'reoffending', 'rehabilitation' and 'naming and shaming' is used naturally. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8.5 | A wide range of structures appears, including participial phrases, relative clauses, a semicolon-linked clause ('employers hesitate to hire someone whose conviction appears...') and a 'where' clause. Nearly all sentences are error-free and punctuation is precise. |
Marked mistakes
-
it can never be fully removed
it can rarely be fully removed (TR)
'Never' is absolute; hedging would be more accurate.
What would raise the band
To reach the top bands, support one or two key claims with concrete evidence, such as a specific country's registry system, and avoid absolute words like 'never'.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay weighs each side with specific reasoning (deterrence versus permanent online records that block employment, errors in conviction, harassment of relatives) and proposes a regulated register for dangerous offenders, making the exception concrete. The 6.0 essay mentions similar ideas but in simpler terms and its exception is less explained. The 6.0 text also contains grammatical slips such as 'it make the system', 'he have no other choice' and 'in most of cases'.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people think that the names and photographs of convicted criminals should be published in newspapers. Others believe this is wrong. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.