IELTS Task 1: Average monthly — Band 4.5 vs 5 samples

IELTS Task 1 — sample answers

The graph below shows the average monthly temperatures in three major cities. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.

Band 5

A real IELTS practice essay scored Band 5 by AI on the topic: The graph below shows the average monthly temperatures in three major cities. Summarise the information by sel. Read it, then get your own essay graded.

Band 5.0

Prompt: The graph below shows the average monthly temperatures in three major cities. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.

At the first glance, the most obvious observation is the rapid changes happening. But once taking a closer look it becomes clear that even though all results had major changes over time they have followed diffrenet paths. while London and New Yrok had experineced tehir coolest days over January and February, Sydney was having some hot days going on around 23 degrees, almost like new year in summer. Later in that year, around June/July they changed places. Sydney started to feel cool dropping almost 10 degreee compared to January while London was having even more dramatic changes getting close to 20 degrees, suggestion a 15 degrees increase, and New York hitting a pick heat of 25 degrees . However, by the end of teh year all cities finsihed where approcimately where they started from, it seems like New York is ending the year with easier chilly days compared to teh begining of the year. Overall, all three cities experineced rapid changes in tempature all around a year while following a predictable upward and downward pattern.

Why Band 5, not 5.5

TR 5 · CC 5 · LR 4 · GRA 5

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 4: The lexical range is limited and repetitive ('changes', 'cool', 'hot', 'days'). There are several notable errors in word choice and word form: 'pick heat' instead of 'peak heat/temperature', 'suggestion' instead of 'suggesting', 'chilly days' is informal and imprecise for a data report. Spelling errors are frequent ('diffrenet', 'Nrok', 'experineced', 'tehir', 'degreee', 'teh', 'finsihed', 'approcimately', 'tempature') and would cause some difficulty for the reader. Less common vocabulary is largely absent.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 5 The response provides a partial overview and identifies some key features (seasonal peaks and troughs, Sydney's inverse pattern), but the description is vague and imprecise. The overview is placed at the end rather than near the beginning, and key data points are often inaccurate or missing (e.g., London's January figure is 5°C, not clearly stated; New York's winter low of ~2°C is not mentioned). The phrase 'suggestion a 15 degrees increase' is unclear, and the comparison of cities is underdeveloped. The response reads more like a narrative recount than a structured data summary.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 5 There is a basic chronological structure (Jan → mid-year → end of year), which gives some overall progression. However, cohesive devices are limited and sometimes faulty ('At the first glance', 'Later in that year', 'However'). Paragraphing is present but inconsistent — the first paragraph functions as an introduction but is too vague, and the overview is misplaced at the end. Referencing is weak ('they', 'all results' without clear antecedents). The flow between sentences is sometimes abrupt.
Lexical Resource Band 4 The lexical range is limited and repetitive ('changes', 'cool', 'hot', 'days'). There are several notable errors in word choice and word form: 'pick heat' instead of 'peak heat/temperature', 'suggestion' instead of 'suggesting', 'chilly days' is informal and imprecise for a data report. Spelling errors are frequent ('diffrenet', 'Nrok', 'experineced', 'tehir', 'degreee', 'teh', 'finsihed', 'approcimately', 'tempature') and would cause some difficulty for the reader. Less common vocabulary is largely absent.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 5 There is some variety in sentence structures (complex clauses with 'while', 'even though', 'compared to'), which shows awareness of grammatical range. However, errors are frequent and sometimes obscure meaning: incorrect tense use ('was having', 'had experienced' used inconsistently), missing articles, incorrect verb forms ('suggestion' for 'suggesting'), and a run-on sentence in paragraph 3. Simple sentences are more accurate than complex ones. Punctuation is inconsistent (missing comma after 'However', inconsistent capitalisation of 'while').

Marked mistakes

  1. suggestion a 15 degrees increase
    suggesting a rise of approximately 15 degrees (TR)
    'Suggestion' is a noun used incorrectly here where a participle ('suggesting') is needed; additionally, the phrasing is grammatically broken and disrupts the data point being reported.
  2. New York hitting a pick heat of 25 degrees
    New York reaching a peak temperature of 25°C in July (TR)
    'Pick' is a spelling error for 'peak'; more importantly, New York's winter low of approximately 2°C — a striking feature of the graph — is never clearly reported, leaving a key data point unaddressed.
  3. diffrenet paths ... New Yrok ... experineced tehir ... degreee ... teh ... finsihed ... approcimately ... tempature
    different paths ... New York ... experienced their ... degree ... the ... finished ... approximately ... temperature (LR)
    There are at least eight distinct spelling errors throughout the essay, which significantly undermine the lexical resource score and would cause difficulty for the reader.
  4. while London and New Yrok had experineced tehir coolest days over January and February, Sydney was having some hot days
    While London and New York experienced their coolest temperatures in January and February, Sydney was recording temperatures of around 23°C (GA)
    The past perfect 'had experienced' is unnecessary and inconsistent with the simple past narrative used elsewhere; 'was having some hot days' is also informal and imprecise for an academic data report.
  5. At the first glance, the most obvious observation is the rapid changes happening.
    Overall, the graph shows that London and New York follow a similar seasonal pattern, peaking in summer and dipping in winter, while Sydney displays the opposite trend. (CC)
    The opening sentence is vague and does not function as a proper overview; in Task 1, the overview should immediately identify the most significant trends, not just state that 'changes are happening'.

What would raise the band

Focus on eliminating spelling errors first — proofread every word carefully — and then rewrite your overview sentence to clearly state the two main trends (London and New York peak in summer; Sydney peaks in winter) with at least two specific data figures to support each point.

Band 4.5 · real student answer

Prompt: The graph below shows the average monthly temperatures in three major cities. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.

The line graph illustrates the comparison of mean weathers in three important cities for each month.

Overall, the highest temperature recorded in the city of New York during July. However, the lowest numbers was recorded in the city of Sydney. In all three urban areas there is a rise and fall of temperature during different months.

Both in London and New York the temperature has reach the peak during July month. During January, both the cities were at lowest numbers of the climate. Whereas, there is a steady increase during Feb in London but the numbers stay the same in New York and rise up quickly during March .Moreover, both hit peak temperature during the month of July with London at 20 degree and New York at 25 degree marking the hottest city among the three. Although, both fell drastically after reaching the top. Two of the cities came back to the lower temperature during December.

Futhermore, in the cities of Sydney it followed different path having the highest temperature during Jan and decreased during March. Moreover, the lowest temperature was marked at the month of July at 15 degree. And the temperature went up after the July .And It went back to the same temperature during December.

Why Band 4.5, not 5

TR 5 · CC 5 · LR 4 · GRA 4

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 4: The lexical range is limited and repetitive. The word 'numbers' is used repeatedly and imprecisely instead of 'temperatures' or 'figures.' The phrase 'mean weathers' is an incorrect collocation — 'average temperatures' is the standard expression. Words like 'climate' are used loosely where 'temperature' is more precise. There are spelling errors ('Futhermore') and informal phrasing ('rise up quickly,' 'went up'). The vocabulary does not demonstrate awareness of topic-specific or academic lexis appropriate for IELTS Task 1.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 5 The response attempts to cover the main features of all three cities but does so in a mechanical and partially inaccurate way. The overview is present but flawed — it states 'the lowest numbers was recorded in the city of Sydney,' which is factually incorrect (Sydney's lowest is around 13°C in July, while New York's lowest is around 2°C in Jan/Feb). Key data points are mentioned but some figures are inaccurate (London's peak is approximately 19°C, not 20°C) and the description of Sydney's trend is vague and incomplete. The response partially satisfies the task but lacks precision and misrepresents some data.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 5 There is a basic organisational structure with an introduction, overview, and body paragraphs, but the progression is unclear and repetitive. Cohesive devices are overused and sometimes misused (e.g., 'Moreover' appears twice in the same paragraph; 'Although' is used incorrectly as a sentence opener without a main clause). Sentences beginning with 'And' are informal and disrupt flow. Paragraphing is present but the final paragraph is underdeveloped and choppy.
Lexical Resource Band 4 The lexical range is limited and repetitive. The word 'numbers' is used repeatedly and imprecisely instead of 'temperatures' or 'figures.' The phrase 'mean weathers' is an incorrect collocation — 'average temperatures' is the standard expression. Words like 'climate' are used loosely where 'temperature' is more precise. There are spelling errors ('Futhermore') and informal phrasing ('rise up quickly,' 'went up'). The vocabulary does not demonstrate awareness of topic-specific or academic lexis appropriate for IELTS Task 1.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 4 There is a limited range of grammatical structures, with most sentences following simple patterns. There are frequent errors in subject-verb agreement ('the lowest numbers was recorded'), verb tense ('has reach the peak,' 'the temperature has reach'), and article use ('during July month'). Sentences beginning with 'And' and the misuse of 'Although' as a standalone clause opener reflect a lack of control over complex structures. Errors are frequent and occasionally impede communication.

Marked mistakes

  1. the lowest numbers was recorded in the city of Sydney
    the lowest temperatures were recorded in New York, which dropped to approximately 2°C in January and February (TR)
    This is factually incorrect — New York has the lowest temperatures (around 2°C), not Sydney (whose minimum is around 13°C). Misreading the graph directly harms Task Achievement.
  2. the temperature has reach the peak during July month
    the temperature reached its peak in July (GA)
    'Has reach' is a grammatical error — the correct present perfect form is 'has reached,' but the simple past 'reached' is more appropriate here. 'July month' is also redundant; 'in July' is correct.
  3. mean weathers in three important cities
    average monthly temperatures in three major cities (LR)
    'Mean weathers' is not a standard collocation in English. The correct academic phrasing is 'average temperatures' or 'mean temperatures'; 'major cities' is also more precise than 'important cities.'
  4. Although, both fell drastically after reaching the top.
    Both cities, however, fell drastically after reaching their peak. (CC)
    'Although' is a subordinating conjunction and cannot begin a standalone sentence without a main clause. 'However' is the correct cohesive device here.
  5. Futhermore
    Furthermore (LR)
    'Futhermore' is a misspelling of 'Furthermore.' Spelling errors in transition words are particularly noticeable in IELTS writing.

What would raise the band

Focus on accuracy of both data and grammar: always double-check figures from the graph before writing, and practise subject-verb agreement and correct verb tenses (e.g., 'temperatures reached their peak' not 'has reach the peak'), as these errors are the single biggest drag on your score across multiple criteria.

Check your essay on this task

Task: The graph below shows the average monthly temperatures in three major cities. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →