The best way to provide enough homes in large cities is to build tall apartment blocks. To what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
Band 6
A real IELTS practice essay scored Band 6 by AI on the topic: The best way to provide enough homes in large cities is to build tall apartment blocks. To what extent do you . Read it, then get your own essay graded.
Band 6.0
Prompt: The best way to provide enough homes in large cities is to build tall apartment blocks. To what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
Many people believe that constructing high-rise apartment buildings is the most effective method to solve housing shortages in big cities. I partly agree with this opinion.
It is true that tall apartment blocks can help cities hold more residents.1 Large cities usually do not have much empty land.1 If developers build high buildings, a single piece of land can provide hundreds of homes.2 This is much better than building low houses which take up a great deal of space.2 For example, in Shanghai, many new residential towers are built to satisfy the demand from young workers. Without these flats, lots of people would struggle to find a place to live.
However, this is not always the best choice. Too many high-rise buildings may bring several problems. Firstly, these buildings can make the city crowded. People may face heavy traffic and less sunlight. Besides, high apartments often cost a lot to build and maintain.3 Some low-income people still cannot afford them.3 Other ways are also useful, such as improving public transport so people can live in nearby small towns and travel to the city centre.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6 · CC 6 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The essay addresses both sides of the argument and states a partial agreement, which is a relevant position. However, the ideas are underdeveloped. The Shanghai example is vague and not well-elaborated. The alternative solution (improving public transport) is mentioned only briefly at the end without proper development. The position is clear but the argument lacks depth and extension.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6 | The essay addresses both sides of the argument and states a partial agreement, which is a relevant position. However, the ideas are underdeveloped. The Shanghai example is vague and not well-elaborated. The alternative solution (improving public transport) is mentioned only briefly at the end without proper development. The position is clear but the argument lacks depth and extension. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6 | There is a clear overall structure with an introduction, a supporting paragraph, and a counter-argument paragraph. Cohesive devices are used (Firstly, Besides, However, Also), but the range is limited and some transitions feel mechanical. Paragraphing is present but the final paragraph tries to cover too many points without clear internal organisation. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | The vocabulary is adequate for the task and generally accurate. There are some attempts at less common expressions (residential towers, satisfy the demand, low-income people), but the overall range is limited and repetitive (e.g. 'build/buildings/built' used frequently). Collocations are mostly correct but not sophisticated. No significant spelling errors. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | A mix of simple and complex sentences is present. The conditional sentence ('Without these flats, lots of people would struggle...') shows some range. However, most sentences are short and simple. There are minor errors in sentence construction and some awkward phrasing, but these rarely impede communication. |
Marked mistakes
-
Other ways are also useful, such as improving public transport so people can live in nearby small towns and travel to the city centre.
Other strategies can also be effective; for instance, investing in public transport infrastructure allows residents to live in satellite towns and commute to the city centre, thereby reducing pressure on urban housing. (TR)
This alternative solution is introduced as a single rushed sentence at the very end of the essay, with no elaboration or supporting evidence, which significantly weakens the argument. -
If developers build high buildings... building low houses... many new residential towers are built
If developers construct high-rise buildings... erecting low-rise houses... many new residential towers have been developed (LR)
The word 'build/buildings/built' is overused throughout the essay; varying the vocabulary with synonyms like 'construct', 'erect', or 'develop' would demonstrate a wider lexical range. -
Besides, high apartments often cost a lot to build and maintain.
Furthermore, high-rise apartments are often expensive to construct and maintain. (CC)
'Besides' is an informal and overused connector; a more formal and precise linking phrase such as 'Furthermore' or 'In addition' would be more appropriate in an academic essay. -
People may face heavy traffic and less sunlight.
Residents may suffer from increased traffic congestion and reduced access to natural sunlight. (GA)
This sentence is grammatically simple and vague; expanding it with more precise noun phrases would improve both grammatical range and lexical precision. -
For example, in Shanghai, many new residential towers are built to satisfy the demand from young workers.
For example, in Shanghai, high-rise residential complexes such as those in Pudong have been developed specifically to accommodate the growing influx of young professionals, providing thousands of affordable units in a compact area. (TR)
The Shanghai example lacks specific detail; adding concrete data or a named development would make the argument more convincing and better developed.
What would raise the band
Focus on developing each idea more fully: for every point you make, add a specific example with detail and then explain how it supports your argument — this single change will most directly raise your Task Response and overall band score.
Check your essay on this task
Task: The best way to provide enough homes in large cities is to build tall apartment blocks. To what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.