The graph below shows the average monthly temperatures in three major cities. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.
Band 5
A real IELTS practice essay scored Band 5 by AI on the topic: The graph below shows the average monthly temperatures in three major cities. Summarise the information by sel. Read it, then get your own essay graded.
Band 5.0
Prompt: The graph below shows the average monthly temperatures in three major cities. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.
The line graph demonstartes the average monthly temperature among three separeted cities during the one year. Overall, it can be mentioned that all three countries had experienced significant fluctuations during the year. Nevertheless, while New York's and London's temperatures rose rapidly at the beginning of the year and then sharply fall, Sydney demonstrated the opposite trand. For the first six months avarage temperature in New York rise sharply from 2 to 25 and reach a peak in Jule, despite the stagnation in the first month. And then rapidly declined to the 6 degrees in the end of the period under research. Same pattern was shown by London, which initially grew steadly from 5 to around 18 degrees to the end of August and then considerably dropped from 18 to around 6 degrees. During the research period Sydnay's results follows the opposite trend. After the stugnation in the first month at approximately 23 degrees,steadly decrease was shown for the next 5 months, reaching a lowest point nearly 13 degrees in July. After which the indicators began gradually return to the start temperature roughtly 22 degrees.
Why Band 5, not 5.5
TR 5.5 · CC 5 · LR 4.5 · GRA 5
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 4.5: There is a limited range of vocabulary with noticeable repetition ('sharply', 'rapidly', 'steadly'). Several spelling errors are present: 'demonstartes', 'separeted', 'trand', 'Jule', 'steadly', 'stugnation', 'Sydnay', 'roughtly'. Word-form errors also appear: 'steadly decrease was shown' (noun/adjective confusion), 'began gradually return' (missing infinitive marker). These errors occasionally impede communication.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 5.5 | An overview is provided and the dominant trends are identified. However, the writer refers to the cities as 'countries', which is a factual error. London's peak is misstated (it peaks around 19°C in July/August, not 18°C in August), New York's peak month is called 'Jule' (July) but the value of 25°C is correct. Sydney's lowest point is described as 'nearly 13°C in July', which is accurate. Key features are present but coverage is uneven — London receives less detail than the other two cities, and the 'stagnation' noted for New York in January/February is a reasonable observation. Overall, the response partially satisfies Task 1 requirements. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 5 | There is a basic organisational structure (introduction, overview, two body paragraphs), but progression within paragraphs is weak. Cohesive devices are limited and sometimes mechanical ('And then', 'After which', 'Same pattern was shown by'). The phrase 'the period under research' is awkward and repeated in spirit. Paragraphing is present but the London and New York data are merged into one paragraph, reducing clarity. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 4.5 | There is a limited range of vocabulary with noticeable repetition ('sharply', 'rapidly', 'steadly'). Several spelling errors are present: 'demonstartes', 'separeted', 'trand', 'Jule', 'steadly', 'stugnation', 'Sydnay', 'roughtly'. Word-form errors also appear: 'steadly decrease was shown' (noun/adjective confusion), 'began gradually return' (missing infinitive marker). These errors occasionally impede communication. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5 | There is a mix of simple and complex sentences, but errors are frequent. Tense inconsistency is a major issue: the writer shifts between past simple, present simple, and present perfect ('had experienced', 'rise sharply', 'reach a peak', 'follows'). Subject-verb agreement errors appear ('Sydnay's results follows'). Some complex structures are attempted ('After which the indicators began gradually return') but are inaccurate. Errors are noticeable but rarely prevent understanding. |
Marked mistakes
-
all three countries had experienced significant fluctuations
all three cities experienced significant fluctuations (TR)
London, New York, and Sydney are cities, not countries; using 'countries' is a factual error that undermines the accuracy of the response. -
average temperature in New York rise sharply from 2 to 25 and reach a peak in Jule
the average temperature in New York rose sharply from 2°C to 25°C, reaching a peak in July (GA)
The verbs 'rise' and 'reach' should be in the past simple tense ('rose', 'reaching') to match the reporting of historical graph data, and units (°C) should be included. -
Sydnay's results follows the opposite trend
Sydney's figures followed the opposite trend (GA)
'Results follows' is a subject-verb agreement error (should be 'follow'), the city name is misspelled, and the tense should be past simple to be consistent with the rest of the description. -
steadly decrease was shown for the next 5 months
a steady decrease was recorded over the following five months (LR)
'Steadly' is not a word; the correct adjective is 'steady' modifying the noun 'decrease', and 'was shown' is an imprecise collocation — 'was recorded' or 'was observed' is more appropriate. -
the indicators began gradually return to the start temperature
the figures gradually began to return to the starting temperature (GA)
After 'began', the infinitive form 'to return' is required; 'gradually' should also be repositioned for natural word order.
What would raise the band
Prioritise grammatical consistency: choose one tense (past simple is standard for Task 1 graphs) and apply it throughout the entire essay, as tense switching is currently the single biggest factor dragging down both your GA and overall band score.
Check your essay on this task
Task: The graph below shows the average monthly temperatures in three major cities. Summarise the information by selecting and reporting the main features.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.