IELTS Task 2: Housing the homeless — Band 6 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Governments should spend money on providing housing for homeless people rather than on building new roads. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Governments should spend money on providing housing for homeless people rather than on building new roads.…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Governments should spend money on providing housing for homeless people rather than on building new roads. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Some people think that governments should spend money on housing for the homeless people instead of building new roads. I agree with this idea because homelessness is a serious social problem, although roads are also needed.

Firstly, having a home is a basic human need. People who live on the street suffer from cold, hunger and illnesses, and many of them die young. If the government provide houses for them, their life will be much better and they can start to look for a job. For example, in Finland, the government give flats to homeless people without any conditions, and the number of homeless people has fell a lot. It also reduces crime, because many homeless people steal or begging to survive.

Secondly, new roads are not always necessary. In many cities there are already enough roads, and building more roads only attract more cars, so the traffic jams and the pollution do not disappear. The money would be better spent on the housing or the public transport, which is more useful for the society.

However, we cannot completely stop building roads. Good roads are essential for economy, because the goods and people need to move quickly between the cities. In developing countries, villages without roads can not have access to hospitals, schools and markets. Besides, roads are often built by private companies or with money from the tolls, so the government will not necessarily have more budget for housing if they stop it.

In my opinion, the government should first make sure that nobody is living on the streets, and then spend the rest of the money on infrastructure. The priority must be given to people rather than to cars.

In conclusion, I agree that providing housing for the homeless is more important than new roads, but both are needed in different situations.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5

The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: Complex sentences are attempted, such as 'building more roads only attract more cars' and 'If the government provide houses', but many contain agreement or tense errors. The subject-verb error in 'building more roads only attract', the faulty perfect form 'has fell' and the mixed verb forms in 'steal or begging' reduce accuracy noticeably.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The essay agrees with spending on housing while acknowledging roads are needed, and the Finland example plus the point that new roads attract more cars show real development. The argument that roads are partly financed by private companies and tolls is a relevant, original consideration, but the final position 'both are needed in different situations' blurs the earlier stance.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The structure is logical: housing arguments, criticism of roads, a counter-argument, then a prioritising conclusion. Sequencing words such as 'Firstly', 'Secondly' and 'However' are used correctly, though 'Besides' and 'also' are somewhat mechanical and 'it' in 'It also reduces crime' could refer to either the flats or Finland.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The writer uses relevant items such as 'homelessness', 'infrastructure', 'tolls' and 'traffic jams', but word form is unstable: 'steal or begging', 'has fell', and the unnecessary 'the housing or the public transport'. These slips do not obscure meaning but show limited control.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 5.5 Complex sentences are attempted, such as 'building more roads only attract more cars' and 'If the government provide houses', but many contain agreement or tense errors. The subject-verb error in 'building more roads only attract', the faulty perfect form 'has fell' and the mixed verb forms in 'steal or begging' reduce accuracy noticeably.

Marked mistakes

  1. the number of homeless people has fell a lot
    the number of homeless people has fallen a lot (GA)
    The present perfect needs the past participle 'fallen'.
  2. many homeless people steal or begging to survive
    many homeless people steal or beg to survive (GA)
    Coordinated verbs must have the same form.
  3. building more roads only attract more cars
    building more roads only attracts more cars (GA)
    The gerund phrase 'building more roads' is singular.
  4. The money would be better spent on the housing or the public transport
    The money would be better spent on housing or public transport (LR)
    General uncountable nouns are used without 'the'.
  5. I agree that providing housing for the homeless is more important than new roads, but both are needed in different situations
    I agree that providing housing for the homeless should take priority over new roads, although roads remain essential in regions that lack them (TR)
    The conclusion should restate the position consistently instead of giving 'both' equal weight.

What would raise the band

Focus on subject-verb agreement and verb forms ('building more roads only attracts', 'has fallen', 'steal or beg'), as these recurring errors are the main barrier to a higher Grammar score.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Governments should spend money on providing housing for homeless people rather than on building new roads. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

I largely agree with this statement, because housing the homeless is among the most cost-effective things a government can do with public money, while the case for new roads is often weaker than it seems. I would qualify this, however, by noting that the answer depends on how developed the existing road network is.

Homelessness is expensive to leave unaddressed. People sleeping rough use emergency rooms, police cells and shelters far more often than those with stable accommodation, and these services are paid for from public funds. Evidence from 'Housing First' programmes, in which people are given permanent homes with no preconditions, shows that most remain housed and that overall public spending falls once the cost of emergency care is taken into account. Finland is the best-known example, and it is the only European country in which the number of homeless people has been falling. For individuals, a stable address is the first step towards finding work, receiving treatment for illness or addiction and rebuilding relationships.

By comparison, the benefits of additional roads in congested cities are frequently short-lived. Studies of urban motorway expansion have found that new capacity encourages more people to drive, so congestion returns within a few years, along with higher pollution. Money spent on housing, or on buses and trams, would usually bring a longer-lasting improvement.

The position changes in countries where basic infrastructure is lacking. In rural areas of the developing world, a single paved road can allow farmers to reach markets and families to reach clinics, and it may lift a whole district out of poverty. Governments in those circumstances cannot sensibly ignore road-building, even if they also face housing needs.

Overall, in countries with extensive road networks, I believe that priority should be given to housing the homeless, but the choice should depend on the specific needs of each country rather than being treated as a universal rule.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: The response states 'I largely agree' and qualifies it clearly by distinguishing countries with extensive roads from those lacking basic infrastructure. Ideas are extended with Housing First evidence, induced demand on motorways and the rural-road example, although the Finland claim is presented as absolute.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The response states 'I largely agree' and qualifies it clearly by distinguishing countries with extensive roads from those lacking basic infrastructure. Ideas are extended with Housing First evidence, induced demand on motorways and the rural-road example, although the Finland claim is presented as absolute.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Paragraphs build in a clear sequence from cost-effectiveness of housing, to the short-lived benefits of roads, to the exception of developing areas. 'By comparison' and 'The position changes in countries where...' mark each pivot smoothly. The thesis in the first paragraph slightly overlaps with the conclusion.
Lexical Resource Band 8 The vocabulary is precise and well collocated: 'sleeping rough', 'stable accommodation', 'preconditions', 'new capacity', 'congestion returns'. Spelling is faultless.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8 The essay shows a wide range of structures, including non-defining relative clauses ('in which people are given permanent homes with no preconditions'), passives, concessions and comparisons. Nearly all sentences are error-free; the long first sentence is the only one that strains clarity.

Marked mistakes

  1. it is the only European country in which the number of homeless people has been falling
    it is one of the few European countries in which the number of homeless people has been falling (TR)
    An absolute claim about 'the only' country is hard to prove and weakens credibility.

What would raise the band

Avoid absolute claims such as 'the only European country' and tighten the first sentence by splitting thesis and qualification, so the position is crisp from the opening line.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 answer makes a financial argument (homelessness costs the public through emergency services, as in Housing First programmes) and links it to the induced-demand effect of new roads, so its reasoning is more specific than the 6.0 answer's claim that housing is a basic need. It also qualifies its position by distinguishing developed and developing countries, whereas the 6.0 answer only says "both are needed". The 6.0 text has errors such as "has fell", "steal or begging" and "only attract more cars".

Check your essay on this task

Task: Governments should spend money on providing housing for homeless people rather than on building new roads. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →