IELTS Task 2: Homework in primary school — Band 6 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Homework should be abolished for primary school children because it puts unnecessary pressure on them. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Homework should be abolished for primary school children because it puts unnecessary pressure on them. To…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Homework should be abolished for primary school children because it puts unnecessary pressure on them. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Some people believe that primary school children should not have homework at all because it makes too much pressure. In my opinion, this view is partly true, but I do not agree that homework should be abolished completely.

The main reason why people want to ban homework is that young children get tired after a long day at school. They need time to play, to meet friends and to rest. When children have a lot of homework, they often feel stressed and some of them start to hate school. In some countries, for example in South Korea, small children go to extra lessons in the evening and they have almost no free time. This is bad for their health and it can cause problems like headaches or sleeping badly.

However, a small amount of homework has some advantages. Firstly, it helps children to repeat what they learned in the lesson. For example, if a child write the new words several times at home, he will remember them better. Secondly, homework teaches children to be responsible. They learn to organise their time and to finish the work by themselves, and this habit is useful when they will go to secondary school. Parents also can see what their children are studying and help them if it is necessary.

I think the solution is not to abolish homework, but to make it shorter and more interesting. Teachers could give tasks for about twenty minutes, like reading a book or doing a simple project with family. In this way, children will not feel pressure and they still develop good study habits.

In conclusion, too much homework is harmful for young children, but a little homework is useful, so I disagree with abolishing it totally.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 5.5

The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: The essay mixes infinitive phrases, relative clauses and conditionals, but errors are frequent: 'if a child write', 'when they will go to secondary school' and the placement of 'also can see'. Most still allow meaning to be understood.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The partial-agreement position is stated at the start and repeated in the conclusion, and both the stress argument and the benefits of 'a small amount of homework' are covered. The South Korea example is relevant but only one sentence long, and the twenty-minute suggestion is not explained.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 'The main reason', 'However', 'Firstly', 'Secondly' and 'In this way' build an easy-to-follow structure. The 'Firstly / Secondly' pair in the third paragraph is rather mechanical, and 'he' for 'a child' is slightly awkward.
Lexical Resource Band 6 Everyday topic vocabulary such as 'extra lessons', 'free time' and 'study habits' is clear. There are some imprecise choices in 'makes too much pressure' and 'sleeping badly', and the word 'homework' and 'children' recur often.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 5.5 The essay mixes infinitive phrases, relative clauses and conditionals, but errors are frequent: 'if a child write', 'when they will go to secondary school' and the placement of 'also can see'. Most still allow meaning to be understood.

Marked mistakes

  1. because it makes too much pressure
    because it puts too much pressure on them (LR)
    'Pressure' collocates with 'put ... on', not 'make'.
  2. if a child write the new words several times at home
    if a child writes the new words several times at home (GA)
    Singular 'a child' requires 'writes'.
  3. this habit is useful when they will go to secondary school
    this habit is useful when they go to secondary school (GA)
    After 'when' referring to the future, English uses the present simple, not 'will'.
  4. Parents also can see what their children are studying
    Parents can also see what their children are studying (GA)
    'Also' goes after the modal verb 'can'.

What would raise the band

Work on verb forms after singular subjects and time clauses ('a child writes', 'when they go'), and add one more detail to the South Korea example so the point is fully supported.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Homework should be abolished for primary school children because it puts unnecessary pressure on them. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Homework for six- to eleven-year-olds is a contentious issue, and I only partly agree with those who want it abolished. Excessive homework does harm young children, but the evidence suggests that the answer is to limit and redesign it, not to remove it.

The case against homework rests on a real problem. Primary pupils already spend about six hours a day in structured lessons, and further evening work can leave them exhausted, anxious and resentful of learning at an age when curiosity is most easily damaged. Research in several countries has found little academic gain from homework at this level, while family evenings that revolve around nagging and tears may do lasting harm to a child's attitude to school. Children also need unstructured play, which is itself essential for social and physical development.

Nevertheless, abolishing homework entirely would sacrifice some genuine benefits. Short, regular tasks teach children habits that are hard to introduce later: writing down what is due, finding a quiet place to work and finishing something without a teacher present. A child who has never practised these routines may struggle when secondary school suddenly demands independent study. Homework also gives parents a view of what is being taught, so that a struggling reader, for instance, can be noticed and helped before the gap widens.

The crucial variable is the type and amount. A sensible policy would limit homework to perhaps fifteen or twenty minutes a night, avoid worksheets of repetitive drill, and favour open tasks such as reading for pleasure, interviewing a grandparent or observing the weather. Such activities build skills without producing pressure, and they can be dropped in busy weeks without penalty.

To sum up, pressure on primary pupils is a valid concern, yet a modest, imaginative amount of homework remains worthwhile, so I would reform it rather than abolish it.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: The 'only partly agree' position is stated in the first lines and maintained through a balanced case against and for homework. Ideas such as unstructured play, the six-hour school day and a struggling reader being spotted by parents are developed, although the research claim is not named.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 The 'only partly agree' position is stated in the first lines and maintained through a balanced case against and for homework. Ideas such as unstructured play, the six-hour school day and a struggling reader being spotted by parents are developed, although the research claim is not named.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Paragraphs move logically from the case against, to the benefits, to the remedy, linked by 'Nevertheless', 'also' and 'Such activities'. The sentence 'The crucial variable is the type and amount' gives the final body paragraph a clear central idea.
Lexical Resource Band 8.5 Vocabulary is precise and natural: 'contentious', 'unstructured play', 'repetitive drill' and 'resentful of learning'. Collocation is accurate throughout, with only 'nagging and tears' sounding slightly emotive for an academic essay.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8 Varied sentence types such as 'at an age when curiosity is most easily damaged', 'so that a struggling reader ... can be noticed' and participle clauses are controlled. The essay is nearly error-free, though one or two sentences are dense.

Marked mistakes

  1. Research in several countries has found little academic gain from homework at this level
    Research in several countries, including Finland, has found little academic gain from homework at this level (TR)
    A named example would turn a general claim into supported evidence.
  2. family evenings that revolve around nagging and tears
    family evenings dominated by conflict and distress (LR)
    This phrase is slightly emotive and informal for an academic essay.

What would raise the band

Replace general references to 'research' and 'evidence' with one named country or study to make the argument even more convincing.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 essay supports its position with concrete detail (six hours of lessons, fifteen to twenty minutes, tasks like interviewing a grandparent) and links benefits to a later outcome, the transition to secondary school. The 6.0 essay makes similar points but with a vague example (South Korea) and inaccuracies such as 'if a child write', 'will go' and 'make too much pressure'. The stronger answer also varies its sentence structures and uses precise collocations, while the weaker one relies on 'Firstly... Secondly' and repeats 'a little/small amount'.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Homework should be abolished for primary school children because it puts unnecessary pressure on them. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →