IELTS Task 2: Degrees and career success — Band 6 vs 8.5 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people think that a university degree is necessary for a successful career. Others believe that practical experience is more valuable. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Band 6 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that a university degree is necessary for a successful career. Others believe that…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Some people think that a university degree is necessary for a successful career. Others believe that practical experience is more valuable. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Many people think that a university degree is the only way to have a successful career, while others say that practical experience is more valuable. I will discuss both of these views and give my opinion.

Firstly, there are some strong reasons to support university education. In many professions, for example medicine, law or engineering, it is impossible to work without a diploma. Also, students at university get deep theoretical knowledge, which they can not get at the workplace. Moreover, graduates usually have higher salaries than people without a degree, and many big companies look at the diploma before they invite a candidate for an interview. University also gives opportunity to meet people and build a network, what can be helpful later.

However, practical experience has its own value. When a person works in a real company, he learn how to solve real problems, work in a team and meet the deadlines. These skills are often more important to employers than theoretical knowledge. For instance, a programmer who has worked on three projects can be better than a graduate who only studied the theory. In addition, studying at university takes four or five years and cost a lot of money, but a person who start working early can earn money and get promotions during this time.

In my opinion, a degree is not necessary for every career, but it is helpful for most of them. The best option is to combine both, for example by doing an internship or a part-time job while studying. In this way students get the knowledge and the experience at the same time.

In conclusion, I believe that both a university degree and practical experience are important. People should choose depending on their profession, but the combination of them is the most successful way.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6 · CC 6 · LR 5.5 · GRA 5.5

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: The range suits the topic ('theoretical knowledge', 'internship', 'network', 'promotions') but there is repetition of 'important' and 'knowledge'. Slips with collocation and word form, such as 'gives opportunity', 'cost a lot of money' (verb form) and 'meet the deadlines', show only partial control.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6 Both views are discussed and the writer gives a relevant balanced opinion: a degree is 'helpful' but not necessary for every career, ideally combined with an internship. Ideas such as 'it is impossible to work without a diploma' are good, but the programmer example is general and the opinion paragraph is shorter than the body.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6 The writing progresses clearly through the introduction, the degree argument, the experience argument, the writer's view and a conclusion. Linkers like 'Also', 'Moreover', 'However' and 'In addition' are used accurately, although often mechanically, and 'what can be helpful later' is a faulty relative link.
Lexical Resource Band 5.5 The range suits the topic ('theoretical knowledge', 'internship', 'network', 'promotions') but there is repetition of 'important' and 'knowledge'. Slips with collocation and word form, such as 'gives opportunity', 'cost a lot of money' (verb form) and 'meet the deadlines', show only partial control.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 5.5 A mixture of simple and complex sentences is used, including 'while studying' and 'who has worked on' clauses. Frequent verb-form and agreement errors ('he learn', 'a person who start', 'cost a lot') and one wrong relative pronoun ('what') appear, though they rarely cause confusion.

Marked mistakes

  1. he learn how to solve real problems
    he learns how to solve real problems (GA)
    The singular subject 'he' needs 'learns'.
  2. takes four or five years and cost a lot of money
    takes four or five years and costs a lot of money (GA)
    Both verbs share one singular subject, so both need the -s ending.
  3. a person who start working early can earn money
    a person who starts working early can earn money (GA)
    The relative clause subject is 'a person', which is singular.
  4. build a network, what can be helpful later
    build a network, which can be helpful later (GA)
    'What' cannot introduce a non-defining clause; use 'which'.
  5. University also gives opportunity to meet people
    University also gives an opportunity to meet people (LR)
    'Opportunity' is countable here and needs an article.

What would raise the band

Proofread for the third-person -s: 'he learn', 'a person who start', 'cost' all lose it. Reading your essay aloud once, subject by subject, would catch most of these slips and push Grammar up by at least half a band.

Band 8.5

Prompt: Some people think that a university degree is necessary for a successful career. Others believe that practical experience is more valuable. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

It is often assumed that a degree is the gateway to a good career, but a growing number of employers claim to value what candidates can actually do. Although I accept that experience matters enormously, I still think a degree remains necessary for many routes to success, and useful for most others.

The case for higher education is strongest in regulated professions. Nobody can practise as a doctor, architect or lawyer without formal qualifications, because the cost of error is simply too high. Even in less regulated fields, a degree signals to employers that someone can study independently, meet deadlines and think analytically; large firms receiving thousands of applications often use it as a first filter. Graduates also earn more over a lifetime on average, which partly explains why families are willing to invest heavily in tuition.

Supporters of practical experience, however, have a convincing counter-argument. Many skills, such as managing difficult clients, working under time pressure or debugging a live system, are learned only on the job. In sectors like digital marketing, construction and the creative industries, a strong portfolio or a record of completed projects can outweigh academic credentials. A young person who begins an apprenticeship at eighteen avoids student debt and may already be running a team by the time a graduate has finished the first year of work.

My own position is that the value of a degree depends on the field. For technical and regulated careers, it is essential, and the theory it provides forms a foundation that experience alone rarely supplies. For practical or entrepreneurial careers, direct experience is usually the better investment. Universities could also narrow the gap by building compulsory placements into their courses.

In summary, neither route is superior in every case. Success is most likely when academic knowledge and real-world practice are combined, and the right balance depends on the profession chosen.

Why Band 8.5, not 9

TR 8.5 · CC 8.5 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8.5: All parts of the task are covered with a position that is nuanced and consistent: a degree is necessary 'for technical and regulated careers' and experience is better for 'practical or entrepreneurial careers'. Ideas are extended with strong specifics (regulated professions, apprenticeships, student debt), though 'learned only on the job' slightly overstates the case and the last suggestion about placements is a minor tangent.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8.5 All parts of the task are covered with a position that is nuanced and consistent: a degree is necessary 'for technical and regulated careers' and experience is better for 'practical or entrepreneurial careers'. Ideas are extended with strong specifics (regulated professions, apprenticeships, student debt), though 'learned only on the job' slightly overstates the case and the last suggestion about placements is a minor tangent.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8.5 Cohesion is skilful, with each paragraph clearly signposted ('The case for higher education is strongest', 'Supporters of practical experience, however, have a convincing counter-argument'). The use of 'Even in less regulated fields' and 'which partly explains why' to build on earlier points is smooth, and the final paragraph synthesises rather than repeats.
Lexical Resource Band 8.5 The vocabulary is wide and precise: 'regulated professions', 'first filter', 'academic credentials', 'compulsory placements' and 'outweigh' are used with natural collocation. Spelling and word forms are accurate throughout, with only a few hedged phrases such as 'a growing number of employers claim' that could be more exact.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 The essay has an extensive range of structures, including concessive 'Although I accept ...', participial 'large firms receiving thousands of applications' and the 'by the time' construction. Punctuation is exact and errors are extremely rare.

Marked mistakes

  1. are learned only on the job
    are best learned on the job (TR)
    'Only' is absolute and unlikely to be true; 'best' keeps the claim defensible.
  2. Universities could also narrow the gap by building compulsory placements into their courses.
    Universities could also narrow the gap by building compulsory placements into their courses, which would give graduates the practical experience employers want. (TR)
    The suggestion is useful but is not linked back to the question's core comparison.

What would raise the band

For a still stronger essay, qualify absolutes such as 'only on the job' and tie your final suggestion about compulsory placements to the central comparison. These tweaks would make the argument as watertight as your language already is.

What separates the higher band

The 8.5 essay distinguishes between types of career (regulated professions versus portfolio-driven fields) and backs this with specific points such as signalling to employers, filtering by large firms and the apprenticeship versus student debt comparison. The 6.0 essay covers the same two sides but with more general statements and ends with a standard 'combine both' compromise without explaining when each is preferable. The 8.5 text is also grammatically cleaner; the 6.0 text has errors such as 'he learn', 'cost a lot', 'what can be helpful' and 'can not'.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people think that a university degree is necessary for a successful career. Others believe that practical experience is more valuable. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →