IELTS Task 2: Performance-based pay — Band 6 vs 8 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Some people think that employees should be paid according to their performance. Others believe all employees in the same job should receive the same salary. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that employees should be paid according to their performance. Others believe all…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.0

Prompt: Some people think that employees should be paid according to their performance. Others believe all employees in the same job should receive the same salary. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

Some people believe that workers should get salary depending on how well they work, but others think that everybody who does the same job must receive the same payment. In this essay I will discuss both views.

Firstly, paying according to performance has some advantages. It is fair that a person who works harder and produces better results receives more money than a lazy colleague. Moreover, this system motivates employees to improve themselves, because they know that their effort will be rewarded. For example, salespeople in many companies get commission for every product they sell, and because of this they try to find more customers. As a result, the company also earn more profit.

On the other hand, equal salary also has its supporters. Firstly, it is difficult to measure the performance of some jobs. How can we compare the work of two teachers or two nurses? If managers decide who is better, they can be unfair and give higher pay to their friends. Secondly, performance pay can create a competition between the colleagues, and they may stop helping each other. This make the atmosphere in the office bad and the stress level very high. In contrast, equal pay gives employees feeling of security and equality.

In my opinion, a mixed system is the best. Every employee should get a basic salary which is the same for the same position, and good workers could get extra bonuses for their results. In this way, the pay stays fair but people still have motivation.

In conclusion, there are strong arguments for both opinions. I think that a basic equal salary with bonuses for performance is the most reasonable solution for most companies.

Why Band 6, not 6.5

TR 6.5 · CC 6 · LR 5.5 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource at 5.5: The vocabulary is adequate and understandable, with some topical words such as 'commission', 'motivation' and 'bonuses'. It is repetitive, though: 'salary', 'pay' and 'payment' recur, and 'bad' in 'the atmosphere in the office bad' is a weak choice. Word-form and collocation slips such as 'create a competition between the colleagues' and 'get salary depending on how well they work' show limited precision.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 Both views are covered and the opinion in paragraph four, a basic equal salary plus bonuses, is clear and consistent with the conclusion. The salespeople-and-commission example supports the pro-performance side, but the nurses and teachers example is posed as a question and never answered, so the equal-pay argument stays thinner than it could be.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6 The structure is clear, with an introduction, a paragraph for each view, an opinion paragraph and a conclusion. Linking relies on mechanical sequencers such as 'Firstly', 'Moreover', 'On the other hand' and a second 'Firstly' in the equal-salary paragraph, which restarts the numbering and feels repetitive. Referencing is mostly clear, though 'This make the atmosphere' points back loosely.
Lexical Resource Band 5.5 The vocabulary is adequate and understandable, with some topical words such as 'commission', 'motivation' and 'bonuses'. It is repetitive, though: 'salary', 'pay' and 'payment' recur, and 'bad' in 'the atmosphere in the office bad' is a weak choice. Word-form and collocation slips such as 'create a competition between the colleagues' and 'get salary depending on how well they work' show limited precision.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 The essay mixes simple sentences with relative clauses ('a person who works harder'), 'because' clauses and conditionals, and most of them are accurate. Recurring subject-verb agreement errors ('the company also earn', 'This make') and missing articles ('gives employees feeling of security') appear in several sentences, but meaning is never lost.

Marked mistakes

  1. the company also earn more profit
    the company also earns more profit (GA)
    'The company' is singular, so the verb needs the -s ending.
  2. This make the atmosphere in the office bad
    This makes the atmosphere in the office unpleasant (GA)
    'This' takes a third-person singular verb, and 'unpleasant' is more precise than 'bad'.
  3. equal pay gives employees feeling of security and equality
    equal pay gives employees a feeling of security and equality (GA)
    The singular countable noun 'feeling' needs the article 'a'.
  4. performance pay can create a competition between the colleagues
    performance pay can create competition between colleagues (LR)
    'Competition' is uncountable here and 'the' is unnecessary when speaking about colleagues in general.
  5. How can we compare the work of two teachers or two nurses?
    It is hard to compare two teachers or two nurses, because their success depends on pupils' or patients' needs rather than on sales figures. (TR)
    A rhetorical question is left without an answer, so the idea is not fully developed.

What would raise the band

Check every verb for agreement with its subject and add missing articles by rereading each sentence slowly, since errors like 'earn', 'make' and 'feeling of security' keep your grammar and lexical scores down. Also answer your own rhetorical questions with a reason or example.

Band 8.0

Prompt: Some people think that employees should be paid according to their performance. Others believe all employees in the same job should receive the same salary. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

How to reward employees is a question every organisation must answer. One school of thought holds that pay should reflect individual results, while the other insists that people doing the same job deserve the same wage. Both positions have a rational basis, but I favour a system in which a fixed base is supplemented by performance-related rewards.

Linking pay to results has an obvious appeal: effort and outcome are connected. A sales representative who consistently exceeds targets generates real revenue for the firm, and it seems reasonable that she should share in it. Such schemes also help retain high achievers, who might otherwise leave for a competitor offering better terms. In addition, they discourage complacency, since a worker's income cannot simply be taken for granted after a few years of service.

Yet the approach has serious limitations. Many jobs produce results that are difficult to quantify. A hospital nurse's value lies in patient care and teamwork, not in a measurable output, and attempts to turn it into numbers can distort behaviour; call-centre staff judged only on the number of calls handled, for example, often hurry customers off the line. Individual bonuses can also damage cooperation, as colleagues compete for credit rather than share information. Equal pay avoids these problems and gives staff a sense of fairness, which is important for morale.

On balance, I believe the most workable solution is a transparent base salary for each role, topped up by bonuses tied to team or company performance as well as individual targets. This preserves a feeling of fairness while still recognising exceptional contributions, and it limits the temptation to undermine colleagues.

To sum up, pure performance pay can motivate but also divide, whereas identical pay is fair but may lack incentive. Combining the two, with clear criteria, offers the best compromise.

Why Band 8, not 8.5

TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Lexical Resource at 8: Both views are weighed thoughtfully and the position, a fixed base plus performance rewards, is stated in the introduction and sustained to the conclusion. Ideas are well extended, for instance the nurse whose value 'lies in patient care and teamwork' and the call-centre staff who 'hurry customers off the line'. The equal-pay side receives one short sentence, so its development is lighter than that of the performance view.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8 Both views are weighed thoughtfully and the position, a fixed base plus performance rewards, is stated in the introduction and sustained to the conclusion. Ideas are well extended, for instance the nurse whose value 'lies in patient care and teamwork' and the call-centre staff who 'hurry customers off the line'. The equal-pay side receives one short sentence, so its development is lighter than that of the performance view.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Progression is logical, moving from appeal to limitations to a compromise, and each paragraph has one clear topic. Linkers like 'In addition', 'Yet', 'On balance' and 'To sum up' are varied and unobtrusive. The referencing is strong, with 'Such schemes' and 'these problems' tying sentences back to earlier points.
Lexical Resource Band 8 The vocabulary is wide and precise: 'complacency', 'quantify', 'performance-related rewards' and 'topped up by bonuses' are all used with accurate collocation. There is no spelling error. Occasional phrases such as 'real revenue' or 'serious limitations' are safe rather than striking, which keeps the score from going higher.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 The essay uses a wide range of structures including a colon, a semicolon, a 'since' clause, participial phrases ('topped up by bonuses') and a 'whereas' contrast, and almost every sentence is error-free. Punctuation is confident.

Marked mistakes

  1. Equal pay avoids these problems and gives staff a sense of fairness, which is important for morale.
    Equal pay avoids these problems and gives staff a sense of fairness, which supports morale and long-term loyalty, although it offers little reward for exceptional effort. (TR)
    The case for equal pay is stated in one sentence and a brief mention of its weakness would make the discussion more balanced.

What would raise the band

Give the equal-pay view the same depth as the performance-pay view, with a specific example, so that both sides of the discussion carry equal weight before your opinion appears.

What separates the higher band

The 8.0 essay illustrates problems with measuring performance using a precise example (call-centre staff rushing customers) and refines its opinion by suggesting team-based bonuses and transparent criteria. The 6.0 essay mentions similar ideas but in more general terms ('lazy colleague', 'competition') and its proposal is less specific. The 8.0 text also uses more varied sentence structures and accurate collocations, while the 6.0 text has errors such as 'the company also earn', 'This make the atmosphere' and 'feeling of security' without an article.

Check your essay on this task

Task: Some people think that employees should be paid according to their performance. Others believe all employees in the same job should receive the same salary. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →