Some people think that the government should provide free healthcare for everyone. Others believe that people should pay for their own medical treatment. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Band 6 and Band 8 answers to the IELTS task “Some people think that the government should provide free healthcare for everyone. Others believe that…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.0
Prompt: Some people think that the government should provide free healthcare for everyone. Others believe that people should pay for their own medical treatment. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Health care is a topic which is discussed in many countries. Some people think that the government must give free medical treatment to all citizens, while others believe that everybody should pay for himself. In my opinion, the first idea is better, and I will explain why.
Firstly, supporters of free healthcare say that health is a basic human right. If medical treatment is paid, poor people can not afford it and they may die from diseases which are easy to cure. For example, in some countries people with low income avoid going to the doctor until the illness become serious. Free healthcare gives equal chances to everyone, no matter how much money he has. Moreover, a healthy population is good for the economy, because people can work more and miss fewer days.
On the other hand, those who disagree say that free medical services are a big burden for the government. The state must collect high taxes from the citizens to pay for hospitals and doctors, and this can be unfair for those who rarely get sick. Also, when treatment is free, some people go to hospital for small problems and the waiting lists become very long. If patients pay, they will be more careful about their health and use the services only when it is really necessary. In addition, private clinics usually have better equipment and more faster service.
Despite these arguments, I still believe that the government should be responsible for healthcare. The problems with the queues can be solved by improving the system, for example by giving a small fee for the unnecessary visits. But no one should be refused treatment because of money.
In conclusion, free healthcare is expensive but it is necessary for a fair society. Therefore I support the first opinion.
Why Band 6, not 6.5
TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 5.5 · GRA 5.5
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 5.5: The range is adequate for the topic, with words such as 'burden', 'taxes' and 'waiting lists', but it is often basic and repeated ('free', 'pay', 'people'). Errors in word form, such as 'more faster service' and 'the unnecessary visits', show weak control of less common items.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | All parts of the question are addressed and the opinion in favour of free healthcare is stated in the introduction and repeated in the conclusion. The point about poor people avoiding the doctor 'until the illness become serious' is useful, but the idea that a fee for 'unnecessary visits' would solve queues is only asserted, not explained. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 6.5 | There is a clear overall progression, with paragraphs for the case for free care, the case against, and the writer's response. Linking words like 'Firstly', 'Moreover', 'On the other hand', 'Also' and 'In addition' are present but somewhat mechanical, and the first paragraph's opening 'Health care is a topic which is discussed in many countries' is a generic filler. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 5.5 | The range is adequate for the topic, with words such as 'burden', 'taxes' and 'waiting lists', but it is often basic and repeated ('free', 'pay', 'people'). Errors in word form, such as 'more faster service' and 'the unnecessary visits', show weak control of less common items. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 5.5 | The essay mixes simple and complex sentences, including relative clauses and a conditional with 'If patients pay, they will be more careful', but errors recur: 'poor people can not afford it' and 'the illness become serious'. They do not usually impede understanding, but they appear in many sentences. |
Marked mistakes
-
until the illness become serious
until the illness becomes serious (GA)
A singular subject needs the third-person -s in the present simple. -
more faster service
faster service (LR)
'Faster' is already a comparative, so 'more' must be removed. -
poor people can not afford it
poor people cannot afford it (GA)
'Cannot' is written as one word in standard English. -
by giving a small fee for the unnecessary visits
by charging a small fee for unnecessary visits (LR)
Fees are 'charged', not 'given', and 'the' is not needed with a general plural noun.
What would raise the band
Proofread for basic agreement errors, such as 'become' and 'more faster', which appear across the essay and are the main thing holding back your grammar score. Also explain how a small fee would reduce queues without harming poor patients.
Band 8.0
Prompt: Some people think that the government should provide free healthcare for everyone. Others believe that people should pay for their own medical treatment. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
The question of who should pay for medical treatment is among the most contested in public policy. Some argue that the state must guarantee free care for everyone, whereas others believe individuals should bear the cost of their own treatment. I support the former view, though with certain safeguards against waste.
The principal argument for universal free care is fairness. Illness is largely unpredictable, and a serious condition such as cancer can cost far more than most families could ever save. Where people must pay, the poorest tend to delay seeing a doctor until a minor problem has become an emergency, which causes avoidable suffering and, ironically, more expensive treatment. Countries with tax-funded systems, such as the United Kingdom, also show that central purchasing can keep drug prices lower than a fragmented private market does. Beyond ethics, a healthier workforce benefits the economy through fewer sick days.
Opponents raise legitimate objections. Funding comprehensive care requires high taxation, and people who rarely use services may resent contributing. Free access can also lead to overuse, with patients attending hospital for trivial complaints and lengthening queues for those in genuine need. Private payment, it is argued, makes individuals more conscious of costs and encourages healthier habits, while competition between providers can raise standards.
Weighing these considerations, I still believe that the benefits of universal coverage outweigh the costs. The risks of overuse can be controlled through measures such as family-doctor gatekeeping or small charges for non-urgent visits, without excluding anyone from essential care. Private clinics can exist alongside the public system for those who wish to pay for faster service.
In conclusion, free healthcare funded through taxation is a more equitable and, in many respects, more efficient model than a system based on personal payment, provided it is managed carefully to prevent misuse.
Why Band 8, not 8.5
TR 8 · CC 8 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8
The weakest criterion is Task Response and Coherence & Cohesion and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: The essay addresses both views and keeps a clear stance for free care 'with certain safeguards against waste', which it develops later with family-doctor gatekeeping and small charges. The UK drug-purchasing example and the argument about delayed treatment becoming 'more expensive treatment' are well supported. Some claims about private competition raising standards are reported but never tested.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8 | The essay addresses both views and keeps a clear stance for free care 'with certain safeguards against waste', which it develops later with family-doctor gatekeeping and small charges. The UK drug-purchasing example and the argument about delayed treatment becoming 'more expensive treatment' are well supported. Some claims about private competition raising standards are reported but never tested. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8 | The sequencing is logical, from the fairness argument to the objections to the weighed conclusion, with a clear topic for each paragraph. Devices like 'Beyond ethics', 'Opponents raise', 'Weighing these considerations' and 'provided it is managed carefully' are natural. A few sentences in the opposing paragraph would benefit from a stronger link back to the writer's argument. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8.5 | The lexical range is wide and accurate: 'universal free care', 'fragmented private market', 'gatekeeping', 'trivial complaints' and 'ironically' are used precisely. Collocations such as 'bear the cost' and 'outweigh the costs' are natural, and there are no spelling or word-form errors. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8 | The essay shows wide structural variety, including 'where people must pay' clauses, 'whereas' contrasts, the passive and participial phrases such as 'with patients attending hospital'. Almost all sentences are error-free. |
Marked mistakes
-
Private payment, it is argued, makes individuals more conscious of costs and encourages healthier habits
Private payment, it is argued, makes individuals more conscious of costs and encourages healthier habits, although evidence suggests it mainly deters poorer patients from seeking care (TR)
The opposing argument is only reported, so a brief rebuttal or evidence would strengthen your evaluation of it.
What would raise the band
To move even higher, give an example or figure when presenting the opposing side so that its strengths and weaknesses are examined as fully as your own position.
What separates the higher band
The 8.0 essay supports its position with specific reasoning (unpredictable catastrophic costs, delayed treatment becoming more expensive, central purchasing lowering drug prices) and answers the opposing arguments with practical remedies such as gatekeeping and parallel private care. The 6.0 essay makes a similar argument but uses broader assertions and a shorter rebuttal. The 8.0 text is almost error-free, while the 6.0 text has slips like 'the illness become serious', 'more faster' and 'a small fee for the unnecessary visits'.
Check your essay on this task
Task: Some people think that the government should provide free healthcare for everyone. Others believe that people should pay for their own medical treatment. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.