English should be the only language of instruction in universities worldwide. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “English should be the only language of instruction in universities worldwide. To what extent do you agree…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.
Band 6.5
Prompt: English should be the only language of instruction in universities worldwide. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
English is the most widely used language in the world, so some people think all universities should teach only in English. I do not agree with this idea, because I think it would create many problems and it is not necessary.
It is true that English instruction has some advantages. First of all, if all universities use one language, students can easily study in other countries and the lectures and books are the same everywhere. Also, a lot of scientific research is published in English, so students who know English can read the newest articles. Graduates with good English can find better jobs in international companies, and this is one reason why many Asian universities already offer courses in English.
However, I believe the disadvantages are more serious. The main problem is that many students do not speak English very well. If lessons are only in English, they will spend their energy to understand the language and not the subject. As a result, their marks can be lower and some talented students may be unable to enter a university at all. For example, a student from a small village in Uzbekistan may be excellent at mathematics, but he would not have a chance if he could not afford English courses. This is unfair.
In addition, a country's own language and culture are important and universities should protect them. If all education is in English, local languages could lose their academic vocabulary, and in the future people may not able to discuss science in their mother tongue. Professors also would have difficulties, because not all teachers speak English fluent.
A better option is that universities offer both. Students can study in their native language and take additional English classes, and universities can have some international programmes in English for those who want them.
In conclusion, I disagree that English should be the only language of instruction, because it would be unfair for many students and harmful for local languages.
Why Band 6.5, not 7
TR 6.5 · CC 7 · LR 6 · GRA 6
The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: There is adequate range ('academic vocabulary', 'mother tongue', 'talented', 'international programmes'), but word form and collocation slip: 'not able to discuss', 'speak English fluent' and 'spend their energy to understand'. These errors do not block understanding but show limited control.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 6.5 | The position is clear (disagree) and the essay acknowledges advantages before arguing that the disadvantages are 'more serious'. The example of a talented mathematics student from an Uzbek village who cannot afford English courses is relevant and gives the argument some substance. The cultural point about local languages losing academic vocabulary is stated but not developed. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 7 | The essay moves logically from advantages to disadvantages to an alternative, with clear topic sentences such as 'However, I believe the disadvantages are more serious'. 'As a result', 'In addition' and 'Also' are used well, though 'First of all ... Also' is a little mechanical. Paragraphing is clear. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 6 | There is adequate range ('academic vocabulary', 'mother tongue', 'talented', 'international programmes'), but word form and collocation slip: 'not able to discuss', 'speak English fluent' and 'spend their energy to understand'. These errors do not block understanding but show limited control. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 6 | The writer attempts conditionals ('If lessons are only in English, they will spend...') and relative clauses with reasonable success. Errors recur in verb groups and adverb forms: 'may not able to discuss' omits 'be', and 'fluent' is used for 'fluently'. Punctuation is sound. |
Marked mistakes
-
people may not able to discuss science
people may not be able to discuss science (GA)
After a modal, 'be' is required before 'able'. -
not all teachers speak English fluent
not all teachers speak English fluently (GA)
An adverb is needed to modify the verb 'speak'. -
they will spend their energy to understand the language
they will spend their energy trying to understand the language (LR)
'Spend ... trying to' or 'spend ... on understanding' is the correct pattern. -
the lectures and books are the same everywhere
the lectures and textbooks would be available in the same language everywhere (TR)
The original claims content, not language, would be identical, which is imprecise.
What would raise the band
Develop the cultural-language argument with one specific effect, as you did for the mathematics student, and check verb groups (modal plus 'be') and adverb forms before submitting.
Band 8.5
Prompt: English should be the only language of instruction in universities worldwide. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
English has become the default language of international science and business, and it is tempting to conclude that every university should simply adopt it. I disagree with the proposal that English be the only language of instruction, because the educational and cultural costs would be considerable and the benefits can be obtained by other means.
The case for a single language rests on practical advantages. Most influential research appears in English, and graduates fluent in it can read the literature, attend conferences and apply for jobs across borders. A common language of instruction would also make it easier for students and academics to move between countries, and it would remove the expense of translating textbooks. The popularity of English-taught degrees in the Netherlands and Scandinavia, which attract thousands of foreign students, shows that the approach can work.
However, those examples involve countries where English proficiency is already very high. Elsewhere, requiring all teaching to be in English would cause many capable students to struggle with the language rather than the content. Comprehension in a second language is slower, and research on bilingual classrooms suggests that learners understand and retain complex material better in their mother tongue. A gifted mathematician from a rural area who has not had access to good English teaching would be excluded, which would entrench the advantage of wealthier, urban applicants. Lecturers would be affected too, since explaining an unfamiliar concept spontaneously is far harder in a foreign language and the quality of teaching could decline.
There is also a cultural dimension. If doctors, lawyers and engineers are educated exclusively in English, their national languages may cease to develop technical vocabulary, and public debate about science and medicine could become inaccessible to ordinary citizens.
A more sensible policy is to teach core degrees in the national language while providing intensive English courses and offering selected programmes wholly in English. This secures the advantages of global communication without sacrificing comprehension or equity.
In conclusion, English instruction should be an option, not a requirement, for universities worldwide.
Why Band 8.5, not 9
TR 8.5 · CC 8.5 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8
The weakest criterion is Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 8: Complex structures are varied and controlled, including 'since explaining an unfamiliar concept spontaneously is far harder in a foreign language' and 'If doctors, lawyers and engineers are educated...'. Nearly all sentences are error-free. A couple of long sentences, such as the one on the gifted mathematician, push close to overloading the reader.
How the examiner scored this answer
| Task Response | Band 8.5 | The position is stated precisely ('the educational and cultural costs would be considerable and the benefits can be obtained by other means') and sustained. The concessions about the Netherlands and Scandinavia are well chosen and then answered with the observation that those countries already have high English proficiency. The research claim about mother-tongue learning is not attributed to a specific source. |
|---|---|---|
| Coherence & Cohesion | Band 8.5 | The argument moves smoothly from the case for English to its limits, then to culture and finally to policy. 'However, those examples involve...' ties directly to the preceding example, and 'There is also a cultural dimension' signals a new angle. Paragraphs are well proportioned, with one central idea each. |
| Lexical Resource | Band 8.5 | Lexis is wide and precise: 'entrench the advantage', 'cease to develop technical vocabulary', 'comprehension in a second language', 'equity'. Collocations are natural and the register is consistently academic. The phrase 'wholly in English' is accurate and economical. |
| Grammatical Range & Accuracy | Band 8 | Complex structures are varied and controlled, including 'since explaining an unfamiliar concept spontaneously is far harder in a foreign language' and 'If doctors, lawyers and engineers are educated...'. Nearly all sentences are error-free. A couple of long sentences, such as the one on the gifted mathematician, push close to overloading the reader. |
Marked mistakes
-
research on bilingual classrooms suggests that learners understand and retain complex material better in their mother tongue
some research on bilingual classrooms suggests that learners may understand and retain complex material better in their mother tongue (TR)
The unspecified research is presented as settled; hedging makes the claim safer. -
would be excluded, which would entrench the advantage of wealthier, urban applicants
could be excluded, which could entrench the advantage of wealthier, urban applicants (TR)
Certain outcomes are asserted for a hypothetical; 'could' fits the argument better.
What would raise the band
Add one precise, attributable example for the bilingual-classroom research, and hedge definitive predictions to make the reasoning fully watertight.
What separates the higher band
The 8.5 essay uses precise, relevant evidence (Dutch and Scandinavian universities where English is already strong, research on learning in a mother tongue) and shows how the problem links to inequality between urban and rural students and to academic vocabulary. The 6.5 essay covers the same sides but with simpler points, and shows lapses such as 'spend their energy to understand', 'may not able to' and 'speak English fluent'. The 8.5 conclusion also reformulates the position ('an option, not a requirement'), while the 6.5 one largely repeats the introduction.
Check your essay on this task
Task: English should be the only language of instruction in universities worldwide. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
0 words
Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.