IELTS Task 2: Exams vs coursework — Band 6.5 vs 8.5 samples

IELTS Task 2 — sample answers

Examinations are not the best way to assess what students have learnt, and continuous assessment is a fairer method. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Band 6.5 and Band 8.5 answers to the IELTS task “Examinations are not the best way to assess what students have learnt, and continuous assessment is a…” — scored on all four criteria, with the mistakes marked. Check your own answer free.

Band 6.5

Prompt: Examinations are not the best way to assess what students have learnt, and continuous assessment is a fairer method. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

Examinations have been the main way of testing students for many years, but nowadays some people say continuous assessment is better. In my opinion, exams still have an important role, although I agree that they are not perfect and they should be combined with other methods.

The main weakness of exams is that they put too much stress on students. A single test at the end of the year decides the result, so a student who is ill or nervous on that day can fail even if he studied hard during the whole year. Also, exams often check only memory. Students learn facts by heart before the test and then forget them very quickly, so it does not show real understanding. In contrast, continuous assessment, which includes projects, presentations and tests during the course, gives a more full picture of student's abilities. Teachers can see the progress and help students who have problems earlier.

However, continuous assessment also have disadvantages. First, it is not always fair because the marks depend on teacher's opinion. A teacher may like some students more than the others, and it is difficult to compare results between different schools. Second, students can get help from parents or from internet when they do projects at home, so it is not clear who really did the work. In exams, everybody has the same conditions and the same questions, which makes the result more objective.

Because of this, I think the best solution is a mix of both. For example, 50 percent of the final grade can come from coursework and 50 percent from a final exam. In this way, students are tested in different ways and the system is more balanced.

To sum up, I partly agree with the statement, but I do not think that exams should be completely replaced by continuous assessment.

Why Band 6.5, not 7

TR 6.5 · CC 6.5 · LR 6 · GRA 6

The weakest criterion is Lexical Resource and Grammatical Range & Accuracy at 6: The wording is appropriate for the topic ('learn facts by heart', 'objective', 'coursework', 'conditions'). However, the range is moderate and some phrases are inaccurate: 'a more full picture' and the article-less 'from internet'. Word choice such as 'the marks depend on' is functional rather than precise.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 6.5 The writer partly agrees and says clearly that exams 'should be combined with other methods'. Both exam weaknesses (stress, memory-only) and continuous-assessment weaknesses (teacher opinion, help from parents) are covered. The 50 percent / 50 percent suggestion is reasonable, but points like 'it is difficult to compare results between different schools' are stated without explanation.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 6.5 The structure is clear: exam weaknesses, continuous assessment weaknesses, then a combined solution. 'Also', 'First', 'Second' and 'In contrast' are used correctly, but the progression inside the exam paragraph is a simple list. Paragraphing is clear and the conclusion mirrors the introduction.
Lexical Resource Band 6 The wording is appropriate for the topic ('learn facts by heart', 'objective', 'coursework', 'conditions'). However, the range is moderate and some phrases are inaccurate: 'a more full picture' and the article-less 'from internet'. Word choice such as 'the marks depend on' is functional rather than precise.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 6 Complex sentences are present ('so a student who is ill or nervous on that day can fail even if he studied hard'), but errors repeat: 'continuous assessment also have', 'student's abilities' and 'teacher's opinion'. These are mostly slips that do not impede meaning. Punctuation is accurate.

Marked mistakes

  1. continuous assessment also have disadvantages
    continuous assessment also has disadvantages (GA)
    'Continuous assessment' is singular and needs 'has'.
  2. gives a more full picture of student's abilities
    gives a fuller picture of students' abilities (LR)
    Use the comparative 'fuller' and the plural possessive 'students'' for general reference.
  3. the marks depend on teacher's opinion
    the marks depend on the teacher's opinion (GA)
    A singular countable noun needs an article before the possessive.
  4. from parents or from internet
    from their parents or from the internet (GA)
    'Internet' takes the definite article.

What would raise the band

Develop each objection with one specific consequence or example (for instance, how teacher bias affects a real pupil) and proofread for articles and subject-verb agreement.

Band 8.5

Prompt: Examinations are not the best way to assess what students have learnt, and continuous assessment is a fairer method. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

The statement that exams should give way to continuous assessment is attractive but overlooks what each method does well. I agree that a single high-stakes exam is a poor measure of learning in many subjects, but I would not call continuous assessment fairer without qualification.

The weaknesses of exams are well known. Because everything rides on one or two sittings, results can be distorted by illness, anxiety or a badly chosen question, and a student who has worked consistently for two years may be judged on a bad afternoon. Time-limited papers also reward certain skills, such as rapid recall and exam technique, while ignoring others like sustained research, collaboration or the ability to revise a draft. Continuous assessment captures these abilities and shows progress over time, which allows teachers to intervene when a pupil begins to fall behind instead of discovering it at the end.

Nevertheless, coursework introduces problems of its own. Marking is more subjective, and standards can differ between teachers and schools, so a grade from one institution may not mean the same as an identical grade elsewhere. Integrity is another concern: when essays and projects are completed at home, there is no guarantee that they are the student's own work, particularly now that online tools can generate acceptable answers in seconds. Students from supportive, well-resourced families may also gain an advantage that they could not have under exam conditions, where everyone faces identical questions and time limits.

For these reasons, I believe fairness is best served by combining the two. Coursework could account for around half of the final grade, with a proportion completed under supervision in class, while a shorter final exam verifies that students can apply their knowledge independently. Subjects differ, too: practical disciplines such as design are better judged through portfolios, whereas mathematics lends itself to timed papers.

In conclusion, exams alone are an inadequate measure, but continuous assessment is not automatically fairer, and a balanced system serves students best.

Why Band 8.5, not 9

TR 8.5 · CC 8 · LR 8.5 · GRA 8.5

The weakest criterion is Coherence & Cohesion at 8: Paragraphing and sequencing are strong: weaknesses of exams, problems of coursework, then a synthesis. 'Nevertheless', 'Integrity is another concern' and 'For these reasons' guide the reader well. The sentence 'Subjects differ, too:' begins somewhat abruptly at the end of the solution paragraph.

How the examiner scored this answer

Task Response Band 8.5 The position is balanced and clearly signalled in the first paragraph ('I would not call continuous assessment fairer without qualification'). Ideas are developed with concrete detail: the 'bad afternoon', online tools generating answers 'in seconds', portfolios for design versus timed papers for mathematics. The claim that supported families give an advantage 'they could not have under exam conditions' is debatable, as tutoring also helps exam candidates.
Coherence & Cohesion Band 8 Paragraphing and sequencing are strong: weaknesses of exams, problems of coursework, then a synthesis. 'Nevertheless', 'Integrity is another concern' and 'For these reasons' guide the reader well. The sentence 'Subjects differ, too:' begins somewhat abruptly at the end of the solution paragraph.
Lexical Resource Band 8.5 Vocabulary is wide and precise: 'high-stakes exam', 'distorted', 'intervene', 'verifies', 'portfolios'. Collocations like 'rides on one or two sittings' and 'sustained research' are natural. A few phrases ('acceptable answers') are slightly loose.
Grammatical Range & Accuracy Band 8.5 The essay uses a variety of structures: 'Because everything rides on...', 'particularly now that online tools can...', 'whereas' contrasts and a participial 'with a proportion completed under supervision'. Sentences are almost entirely error-free. Punctuation is controlled throughout.

Marked mistakes

  1. Students from supportive, well-resourced families may also gain an advantage that they could not have under exam conditions
    Students from supportive, well-resourced families may also gain a larger advantage than they would under exam conditions (TR)
    Private tuition also helps exam candidates, so the absolute claim needs qualifying.
  2. Subjects differ, too:
    The best balance will also vary by subject: (CC)
    A fuller linking phrase would connect this idea to the proposed mix more smoothly.

What would raise the band

Test your own claims for exceptions, as with the family-advantage point, and connect the final subject-specific idea to the proposed mix with a fuller transition.

What separates the higher band

The 8.5 essay specifies which skills each method measures (recall vs. sustained research and revision) and raises less obvious points such as unequal home support and AI-generated coursework. It also adapts the conclusion by subject (portfolios for design, timed papers for maths). The 6.5 essay has a similar 50/50 solution but its arguments are more general, with grammatical errors ('continuous assessment also have', 'more full picture', 'teacher's opinion') and mechanical sequencing ('First... Second').

Check your essay on this task

Task: Examinations are not the best way to assess what students have learnt, and continuous assessment is a fairer method. To what extent do you agree or disagree?

0 words

Free, no card. Sign in with Google and your essay goes straight to the examiner with this task filled in.

Read IELTS Writing tips on the blog →